That's one helluva thing to bestow upon a young girl. Beth's scars may have faded even more by the time the recently confirmed season five comes around, but they will always be there to remind viewers of her traumatic journey so far. Seemingly, their two supernatural connections would have linked them together, were it not for Beths interference. ---- yer its nice for them/us to get the reward in season 3, and to hear kelly reilly talk about it is really interesting. Beth Dutton. Josh Lucas, who plays a young John Dutton in Yellowstone, talks . Before the tragic incident, Beth was nervous while on her horse, causing it to get spooked. Before his father took over the ranch, his ancestors had already moved to the area. A longstanding sibling . Things have arguably grown even more acidic between the siblings in Season 2, with Beth's constant barrage . You should try zoomba. John was close to Jamies birth mother and he was the father of Jamie. Maybe it was the writers fault, thats what I assume, but that scene did not fit with Evelyns previous dealings with Beth, they add. Beths big brother drives her to the nearby Native American Reservation for Beth to get an abortion. John begged Jamies birth mother not to marry him because he knew what kind of man he was. Express. Thankyou. She lost respect for him after he agreed to the surgery. All too true. DON'T MISS:Money Heist season 5 theories: Rios death sealed in throwback clue[THEORY]The Walking Dead: Showrunner opens up on dark final season[INTERVIEW]Below Decks Captain Lee addresses season 9 disappearance[INSIGHT]. While Evelyn comforts Beth after she becomes a woman, she also gives a harsh speech about what it means to be a woman in the world. You dont toughen your daughter by sneering, mocking, cold-eyed dislike. No wonder, indeed. Evelyn Dutton existed in flashbacks STRICTLY for Beth's story, and no other reason at all. Rip loves Beth dearly, and he won't be mad at her when he finds out the truth of what happened. Yes it really does explain beth, but how could Kevin Costner marry someone so cold? She constantly carries the guilt of the accident even though it was not her fault. In the end, it all makes for excellent fictional drama. Its no secret that throughout her appearance in Yellowstone, Beths mother, Evelyn Dutton was tough on her. His parents are James and Margaret Dutton. In a post paying tribute to Mols performance in the series, user klaise1 asked: Why does she hate Beth? The fierce daughter of Kevin Costner's John Dutton is a take-no-prisoners businesswoman who's gaping emotional wounds serve as both a source of strength and weakness. The latter is without Beths knowledge and consent. Creedence Clearwater Revivals Have You Ever Seen The Rain Gives A Glimpse Before The Bands Split, 10 Popular Country Songs That Were Originally Cover Hits, 18 Best Country Songs About Best Friends to Add to Your Playlist, 15 Best Country Songs About Faith To Build Your Confidence In God And His Word, 25 Best Country Songs About Home and Hometowns You Should Listen To, Here Are the 15 Best Country Songs About Working Hard To Keep You Motivated. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Seventh - Unknown. I am re-watching Season 1, and when we are introduced to Evelyn Dutton (John's wife), she is downright hostile to Beth (horse riding scene). She continues to wrestle with what ifs, self-loathing, guilt, and the weight of keeping her biggest truth from Rip. Evelyn may have been trying to push Beth out of her comfort zone in order to help her become more confident. There is no way to recover from that massive of a procedure privately. Now that we have addressed that, there is another plot point Yellowstone has ignored. 'Belle de Jour' Movie Review: The Meaning of a 65-Year Opus. At least Beth checked herself somewhat and decided to deal with Rip vs using him and belittling him because of his background. And for that, we cant fault Yellowstones writers at all. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". Categories . Related: These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Fans will have to wait and see if any more flashbacks explain their strained relationship any further, but a new theory has proposed the upcoming Yellowstone prequel could also reveal more. That whole scenario still seems so out of place to me, they cite, calling it jarring., Thats an excellent one-word description of the flashback, to be sure. Bethany Dutton, the second youngest child and only daughter to ranch owners John Dutton and Evelyn Dutton. Christina told Jamie that he did exactly what he said he was going to do. Karma., But its u/meemf that gets to the core of Beth Dutton, adding I often think she acts so emotionless and distant because she is trying to reject her own emotions and appear unbreakable.. Her small yet impactful role in the modern Western drama has invariably shown her being tough and callous towards teenage Beth (Kylie Rogers). But Beth got a raw deal from mommy dearest, one Reddit user writes in response to the original poster. Check out the adventures of Chewy the Top Pom on Eclectic *Pup* Click on the pic to travel through the wormhole! I also knew a girl our age then who was killed when she accidentally dropped the reins and her horse tripped on them, threw her and landed on top of her. This has huge implications. Who knows. However, this approach backfired, and resulted in Beths mother gettng crushed by a horse. Evelyn says that everything will change for Beth starting that day. How Helen Keller Overcame the Barriers To Speech, Clocktane Octane Skin: Embodying a Timeless Style, Aldor vs. Scryers: Rogues Guide to Shattrath City, The Babyface Brothers Musical Legacy: Kevon, Melvin, and Kenneth. Beth married her boyfriend, Rip Wheeler, in an impromptu ceremony as she prepared to confront Jamie. She . Jon and Evelyn Dutton had a child. They were raised on the same ranch. Jamie does not realize until he is signing Beth up for the procedure that for her to get an abortion there, she must also get sterilized. Does Tate Dutton Fail to Escape Deaths Grasp in Yellowstone? Maybe there was real hate. The wig is made of premium Japanese Futura synthetic fibers that give a realistic look like human hair. In the last moments of Lee, the brother in Kayces soul wakes up and ties to heal Lee but Lee finally succumbs to the injuries caused to him by the wounds of the bullet. When Beths riding scares the horse, it has a domino effect. Yellowstone Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. She feels guilty about the accident and, at one point, even believes that she killed her mother by being scared when they went horseback riding that time. He was a very wise and compassionate man, and he passed down his values to his son. "But after being treated like you're weaker long enough, you'll start to. John and Evelyn were blessed with four children, two of which are brothers and one of which is a sister. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.Privacy Policy - Affiliate Disclosure. She wasn't born tough, she was made tough. I dont agree with it and the scene of falling off the horse could have been a moment Of compassion between mother and daughter but it shows how tough this woman really was. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. She is the third youngest of the Dutton siblings, with Kayce being the youngest. Beth Dutton. So, what have we learned about why Beth is so mean? What happened to her is explained in the episode of No Good Horses. Hollywood Life But we see flashbacks mostly from beths perspective which taints the memory. Her mother discovers shes just started her period for the first time and goes to comfort her. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. However, that doesnt seem to be the case at all. The details of the accident are not clear, but it seems that Beths horse became spooked and threw her off, causing her mother to be fatally crushed by another horse. She was a strong, independent woman who loved her family and her horses. Beths mother died in a horseback riding accident when Beth was just six years old. Jamie became a pariah after learning that John had lied to him his whole life and that he was not a Dutton. Yellowstone TV: Fans Debate Whether Evelyn Dutton Was Too Hard on Beth, re-watching flashbacks with her mother, Evelyn, bottle it up and channel that anger and hurt into strength. A Look at Kelsey Asbille and Her Role as Monica On Yellowstone. Guess I kinda just watch the show, watch them all try to co-exist and figure it all out. He served as a livestock agent and was set to take over the ranch for his father, John Dutton III. I Lov this series Yellowstone its actresses & actors! Introducing Evelyn Dutton (played by Gretchen Mol) via flashback, in the final moments before a fatal riding accident, reframes a lot of what the audience understood about the Dutton family.. A wildfire broke out on their ranch and Evelyn refused to leave her horses behind. We just watch the show from their perspective. However, he has not remarried yet or had a serious relationship. Evelyn was a successful horse breeder who raised quarter horses on her ranch in Montana. She fell off of her horse while riding with Beth and Kayce. Dreamer. Why does Evelyn Dutton hate Beth? The self-described "tornado . Its not an excuse, but I was just a better father when she was with me.. Despite having a chance to clarify that Beths sterility is due to tubal ligation, it seems to have doubled down on the implausible take that Beth had a full hysterectomy. Instead of offering comfort, the Dutton mother chastises Beth for being so scared of the animal. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Jamies biological father was sent to prison for the murder of his mother. Subscribe to our newsletter for new stories, tips & events. 15 Facts About Mousesack From The Witcher? Not every character on the show has really done much work on their self. So sad. Kayce left to be with Monica when she got pregnant with Tate and was branded out of spite by John. However, it is Jamies latest betrayal of their father that gives Beth the green light to potentially realize her darkest dream. Maybe her mom knew this was a make or break moment for Beth as young girl and really wanted to make sure her tough love didnt amount to nothing? Evelyn was known for being a tough mother, especially to Beth. I know she's a very popular character, but I feel like she just sucks up the atmosphere on the show. Chick-fil-As Peach Milkshake: The Perfect Summer Treat! Beth is horrified and stung by lifes strange reward for Jamie, and Season 5 sees her stew in it with more sadness than anger most of the time. The beginning of episode three of the first season of Yellowstone brings us our first flashback, during which we learn how Beth developed that chip on her shoulder, and boy is it ever a doozy. While riding a horse with her mother and brother, Beth's hesitation resulted in her mom landing hard on the ground and getting crushed by one of the animals. If youre as invested in Yellowstone as we are, then you already know about Beth Duttons rocky relationship with her late mother. One theory suggests that Beth's hatred for Jamie is due to an unhealthy sibling rivalry that dates back to early in their lives. He doesnt know that she was pregnant with his child. It is hard for him to accept that Beth denies him. Thats why Im going to have to be harder on you, honey. Some fans, however, still dont think enough has been said on the matter. That scene brought to mind that when we were kids, my 6 year old sister was on a Male horse that ran between a female horse who was spooked and tethered to a post in an arena. Let her undo it. While Beth managed to find and bring her father to the scene, they were too late. I do feel bad for this whole families tragedy due to the death of their mother & wife ! This explanation makes sense to me. Evelyn Dutton takes her last breath when John reaches her. Though Beth is able to find her father and bring him to her injured mother, they are too late. She is the mother of Lee, Beth and Kayce Dutton. We start to understand her layers.. Yet as Redditor AmericanWanderlust cites: Wasnt the mom trying to toughen Beth up? Evelyn was out riding with Kayce and Beth when her horse spooked and fell on her, resulting in her death. Because youre going to hate it sweetheart. Evelyn Dutton was John Dutton 's wife and mother of Lee, Jamie, Beth and Kayce. It is a burning question on so many #yellowstone viewers' minds. I like the show, but the way they hide characters motivations from the audience for years is a little ridiculous. Its a storyline Yellowstone would shed significant light on throughout the first three seasons, with flashbacks in Season 3 lending harsh weight specifically to the Beth & Jamie dynamic. Lucille Ball told everyone in Hollywood, when she first arrived, that she was from Butte, Montana. For starters, she only made four appearances in the show, all of which were in a flashback or simply photos of her shown during the show. It led to many fans thinking that she hated her. Evelyn . Monica Long was married to Kayce and they had a son named Tate. She made her aware that she was entering a world dominated by men. Most of her mentality and mental issues definitely stem from her mother and her mothers death in her environment, she was bound to be a little tougher, growing up on a ranch and having three brothers and a dozen ranch hands influencing the way you think and talk, her mother was probably one of her few gateways into femininity. Yellowstone fans found out in season 3 that Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn Dutton when he was just three months old. My best guess is and I've said it before perhaps Evelyn and John only wanted boys instead of girls, and Evelyn resented having Beth. How could that not turn a switch off in Beth? Learn More. In one episode, during Evelyns death anniversary, Beth, struggling to cope, bathed in a trough and drank champagne to wash away her guilt. About halfway through their meal, John's . The shows board on the social media platform continues to prompt thought-provoking discussion on our favorite characters.